Navigating Termination for Cause - A Step-by-Step Guide

Note: Links to our free templates are at the bottom of this long guide.
Also note: This is not legal advice

Introduction

Terminating an employee for cause can be a complex process, and employers should take care to ensure that the decision is taken within the law. When a termination for cause is necessary, it’s important to understand the requirements and legal implications of such a decision - failure to do so could mean facing serious consequences, including compensation claims. But understanding the process doesn’t have to be difficult. With our step-by-step guide, employers can navigate termination for cause with confidence and easily access Genie AI’s free template library today.

The first step when considering termination for cause is to become familiar with all relevant laws and regulations, including any collective agreements that may apply to the employee in question. Employers should also be aware of their employee’s rights under those laws; this includes understanding notice periods that must be observed, as well as potential appeal and grievance procedures which may apply in certain circumstances - particularly if there is a risk of wrongful dismissal claims being brought against the employer.

Next comes creating a comprehensive document outlining why termination for cause is necessary; such documents will include details on what actions or behaviors constituted breach of contract, any relevant evidence that informed the decision making process (such as performance reviews or disciplinary records), what steps were taken prior to taking this route (such as warnings or attempts at resolution) and an outline of how these documents demonstrate clear breach of contract by the employee in question.

From here, employers should consider whether there are any provision available which could lead to non-termination outcomes - such as redeployment or counselling - before deciding whether this route has been exhausted or not feasible based on individual corporate objectives or resources. Doing so can help shield employers from future risk emanating from potential claims by demonstrating due diligence on their part when terminating an employee for cause.

It’s also important to remember that legal advice may need to be sought throughout this process - especially when specific conditions require special consideration (such as pregnancy/maternity leave). Doing so will give you further assurance that you are following correct procedures which are compliant with applicable laws whilst protecting your business from liability associated with inappropriate handling of termination decisions made without properly consulted counsel where required.

Finally, it’s worth noting that our free open source template library offers high quality templates covering many aspects relating to terminations for cause in various jurisdictions; these templates are powered by millions of datapoints collected from around the world teaching Genie AI what market-standard terminations look like - enabling anyone access draft legal documents without having a Genie AI account nor pay expensive lawyer fees in order do so! Read on below for our step-by-step guidance and information on how you can access our template library today!

Definitions

Cause (for Termination): Grounds or reasons that justify an employee’s termination.
Statutes: Laws passed by a legislature.
Regulations: Rules or laws set by a government agency.
Case Law: A legal principle established through court decisions.
Termination Protocols: Procedures or steps to follow when terminating an employee.
Written Notice: A formal document stating the reasons for termination.
Legal Challenge: An attempt to overturn or change a law or legal decision.
Gathering Evidence: Collecting information to support a legal argument.

Contents

1. Establishing the Grounds for Termination
2. Research relevant state and federal laws
3. Review company policies and procedures
4. Consult with legal counsel, if necessary
5. Following Proper Termination Protocols
6. Prepare a written notice of termination
7. Schedule a meeting with the employee for the purpose of delivering the notice
8. Document the meeting and outcome
9. Managing Potential Risks
10. Consider the potential impact of the termination on other employees
11. Assess the potential for a legal challenge
12. Prepare a plan to respond to any claims or challenges
13. Exploring Alternative Solutions
14. Identify potential alternatives
15. Analyze the potential benefits and drawbacks of each alternative
16. Develop a plan to implement the chosen alternative
17. Preparing for the Meeting
18. Anticipate how the employee may react
19. Prepare a response to any objections or questions
20. Set expectations for the meeting
21. Delivering the Termination Notice
22. Reiterate the decision and reason for termination
23. Respectfully answer questions or objections
24. Inform the employee of the available resources
25. Following Up After the Meeting
26. Document the meeting and outcome
27. Collect any personal items from the employee
28. Follow up on any outstanding questions or issues
29. Completing the Termination Process
30. Calculate and issue final payment
31. Notify HR, payroll, and other relevant parties
32. Process any necessary paperwork
33. Maintaining Positive Relationships
34. Respond to inquiries in a timely manner
35. Maintain a professional attitude
36. Respect the employee’s privacy
37. Evaluating the Process
38. Review the decision-making process
39. Analyze the outcome
40. Identify areas for improvement

Get started

Establishing the Grounds for Termination

• Identify the employee’s performance issues that may lead to termination
• Review the employee’s personnel file for evidence of the performance issues
• Document any instances of misbehavior, including any warnings issued
• Identify any employee or union contracts that may affect the termination process

Once you have identified and documented the performance issues, you can move on to the next step.

Research relevant state and federal laws

• Consult state and federal laws to ensure there are no legal issues with the termination
• Read through and understand the relevant laws in order to determine the grounds for termination
• Research any relevant court cases and relevant regulations related to the termination
• Record the relevant laws and any other information found during research
• Take notes while researching and document any potential issues and consequences related to the termination
• Make sure that the termination is in compliance with the relevant state and federal laws
• When complete, you should have a thorough knowledge of the relevant laws and regulations related to the termination.

Review company policies and procedures

• Read and fully understand the company’s written policies and procedures regarding termination for cause
• Make sure to understand the company’s definition of ““cause”” and how it applies to the current situation
• Check whether the current employee’s job position is covered in the policies and procedures
• When you can confirm the employee’s job position is covered in the policies and procedures, you can check this step off your list and move on to the next step.

Consult with legal counsel, if necessary

• Research and understand the applicable laws in the state or province in which the employee works
• Engage an experienced labor and employment attorney to confirm that the termination for cause is legally compliant
• Have the attorney draft the termination notice, if necessary
• Be prepared to provide a detailed account of the incidents leading up to the termination
• Once you have consulted with legal counsel, you can proceed with the termination according to your company’s policies and procedures.

Following Proper Termination Protocols

• Develop a clear understanding of the policy or procedure for terminating an employee for cause
• Gather all relevant documentation, including previous warnings and communications, that will be used to support the termination
• Have a witness present during the termination conversation if possible
• Deliver the termination notice in person and discuss the situation calmly and professionally
• Allow the employee to respond to the notice, and take notes of the conversation
• Once the conversation is over, provide the employee with a copy of the written termination notice
• When the termination process is complete, be sure to document the event in the employee’s personnel file
• You will know that you have completed this step once you have delivered the termination notice in person and provided the employee with a copy of the written notice.

Prepare a written notice of termination

• Draft a written notice of termination that outlines the reasons for the employee’s termination
• Ensure that the notice includes a detailed description of the employee’s misconduct
• Review the notice with a lawyer or human resources professional to ensure it is legally compliant
• Once the notice is finalised, sign it and keep a copy for your records
• You will know when you can check this off your list when the notice is finalised and signed.

Schedule a meeting with the employee for the purpose of delivering the notice

• Contact the employee to schedule a meeting for the termination
• Have a witness present for the meeting
• Inform the employee that the meeting is for the purpose of delivering a notice of termination
• Read the notice of termination to the employee
• Discuss the reasons for the termination
• Allow the employee to respond
• Answer any questions the employee may have
• When the meeting is concluded, you can check this off your list and move on to the next step.

Document the meeting and outcome

• Make sure to record the meeting minutes, including the employee’s response, any questions asked and any promises made
• Make sure to document the entire process from start to finish in an organized manner
• Ensure that all relevant personnel are copied in on the documentation
• Ensure that all documentation is stored securely for reference and protection
• Once the meeting and documentation is complete, you can check this step off your list and move on to the next step.

Managing Potential Risks

• Review any labor-related laws that may apply to the potential termination
• Consider any potential legal risks of the termination, such as wrongful termination
• Take into account the potential impact of the termination on other employees
• Make sure that the decision to terminate is based on clear evidence and valid reasons
• Consult with your legal counsel or HR department as needed
• Document all of your decisions, actions, and conversations related to the termination

Once you have taken all of the necessary steps to review potential risks, you can move on to the next step.

Consider the potential impact of the termination on other employees

• Analyze the potential impact of the termination on other employees (e.g., morale, productivity, etc.)
• Determine the potential effect of the termination on the team structure and dynamics
• Assess the potential for a communication plan to address the impact of the termination on other employees
• Determine whether any other employees are likely to be affected by the termination
• Identify any potential risks associated with the termination related to its impact on other employees
• When you have considered the potential impact of the termination on other employees and identified any potential risks, you can move on to the next step.

Assess the potential for a legal challenge

• Research the legal issues associated with termination for cause in the relevant jurisdiction
• Analyze the business’s policies and procedures, and any applicable employee handbooks
• Review the employee’s job description and any applicable contracts
• Consider any other applicable laws and regulations

How you’ll know when you can check this off your list and move on to the next step:

• Once you have conducted research and reviewed the applicable documents, you will be able to assess the potential for a legal challenge and determine whether you should proceed with the termination for cause.

Prepare a plan to respond to any claims or challenges

• Document the evidence that supports the decision to terminate
• Prepare the company’s response to any claims or challenges
• Draft a timeline of events to help anticipate and respond to any claims
• Consider any additional information that may be needed to support the decision
• Assess the potential legal risks and liabilities associated with the decision
• When the plan is finalized, review it with the executive team to ensure all potential issues have been addressed
• When the plan is approved, the next step is to explore any alternative solutions

Exploring Alternative Solutions

• Research any other solutions available that could potentially address the issue without termination
• Consider the timing of any alternative solutions and the impact on the employee, other employees, and the business
• Discuss the alternatives with the employee and any other relevant stakeholders
• Record any decisions or agreements made during the exploration of alternatives
• Once all potential alternatives have been explored and decisions have been made, you can move on to the next step.

Identify potential alternatives

• Research applicable laws and regulations to determine what constitutes “cause” for termination
• Consult with your company’s legal team to ensure that all legal requirements are met
• Talk to other members of your management team to get their input on potential alternatives
• Analyze the financial implications of any potential alternatives
• Consider the impact that terminating the employee could have on the company culture

You’ll know you’ve identified potential alternatives when you have a list of all potential alternatives that can be pursued.

Analyze the potential benefits and drawbacks of each alternative

• Make a list of the potential benefits and drawbacks of each alternative
• Compare the potential benefits and drawbacks of each alternative
• Determine which alternative is most beneficial and least detrimental
• Decide which alternative is best to pursue
• When you have completed the analysis and determined which alternative is best to pursue, you can check off this step and move on to the next.

Develop a plan to implement the chosen alternative

• Create a timeline for implementation of the chosen alternative
• Identify and document any resources, such as staff or materials, that are needed to implement the selected alternative
• Outline steps for communicating the plan to stakeholders, such as employees or the board
• Identify any legal considerations, such as those related to employee contracts, that need to be addressed
• Develop a system to measure and track progress on the plan

How you’ll know when you can check this off your list and move on to the next step: Once you have outlined a plan for implementation, communicated the plan to stakeholders, identified any legal considerations that need to be addressed, and developed a system to track progress, you can move on to the next step.

Preparing for the Meeting

• Develop an agenda and ensure that you have all necessary documents and resources ready for the meeting
• Prepare any necessary documents to support the termination (e.g. performance reviews, emails, etc.)
• Schedule a meeting room and ensure that there are no distractions
• Ensure that relevant HR personnel and/or legal counsel are present
• When you have completed these tasks you will be ready to move on to the next step, which is anticipating how the employee may react.

Anticipate how the employee may react

• Make a list of potential reactions from the employee.
• Identify potential areas of resistance or anger.
• Consider how you will handle any potential reactions.
• Prepare yourself emotionally to handle any challenging reactions.
• When you feel ready to handle any potential reactions and are emotionally prepared, you can check this step off your list and move on to the next step.

Prepare a response to any objections or questions

• Research the company’s policies and procedures, and be prepared to answer any questions the employee may have about the relevant sections
• Compile a list of potential questions or objections the employee may have, such as why they are being terminated and the evidence the company has to support the decision
• Make sure to include the legal considerations relevant to the situation in your response
• Have a plan in place to address any issues raised by the employee
• You will know that you have completed this step when you have collected all of the relevant information and crafted a response to any potential objections or questions.

Set expectations for the meeting

• Identify the employees who will be present at the meeting
• Set a time and place for the meeting
• Decide how the meeting will be conducted (e.g., in-person, over the phone)
• Prepare any documents or materials that may be relevant (e.g., letters of termination)
• Develop a plan for how the termination will be handled (e.g., who will be responsible for notifying the employee, who will be present during the meeting, etc.)
• When you have all of the above items completed, you can move on to delivering the termination notice.

Delivering the Termination Notice

• Prepare the termination letter in advance, ensuring that it meets all legal requirements.
• Make sure that the meeting is in a private space, and that all necessary personnel are present.
• Introduce the purpose of the meeting and reiterate that the decision has already been made.
• Deliver the termination letter and explain the details in a concise and professional manner.
• Allow the employee to ask questions and provide feedback.
• Summarize the conversation and provide materials that provide additional information.

You can check this off your list and move on to the next step when you have delivered the termination letter and allowed the employee to ask questions and provide feedback.

Reiterate the decision and reason for termination

• Clearly, calmly, and respectfully repeat the decision and reason for termination
• Make sure the employee is clear on why they are being terminated and that there is no misunderstanding
• Do not go into detail on the employee’s performance or behavior - keep your explanation brief
• Respectfully answer any questions or objections the employee may have
• When the employee is clear on the decision and the reason for termination, this step is complete.

Respectfully answer questions or objections

• Listen carefully and acknowledge the employee’s questions or objections.
• Respectfully answer the employee’s questions or objections, staying as factual as possible.
• Avoid getting into any arguments with the employee.
• If the employee’s questions or objections become too heated, offer to continue the conversation later or to have a third-party mediator present.

You can check this step off the list and move on to the next step when the employee’s questions and objections have been addressed and are no longer an issue.

Inform the employee of the available resources

• Provide the employee with a list of resources available to them, such as legal advice, unemployment insurance, financial assistance, or job search services.
• Explain the details of the resources available, such as how to access them, and any deadlines that may apply.
• Make sure to provide the employee with a contact person or website to get further information, if needed.
• Let the employee know they can file a grievance if they feel they have been treated unfairly.
• Ask the employee if they have any questions or require more information.

You will know this step is complete when the employee is aware of the resources available to them, and has all the necessary information to take advantage of those resources.

Following Up After the Meeting

• Send the employee a written communication summarizing the facts of the meeting and confirming the outcome of the decision
• Send a copy of any relevant documentation, such as performance evaluations or disciplinary notices, to the employee
• Ensure the employee understands the terms of their termination
• Follow up with the employee in a timely manner to discuss any questions or concerns they may have
• When the employee acknowledges their understanding of the facts of their termination, check this off your list and move on to the next step.

Document the meeting and outcome

• Take detailed notes during the termination meeting
• Make sure to note the reason for termination, the employee’s reaction and any other relevant information
• Have the employee sign off on the document and keep a copy for your records
• When the meeting is complete, make sure you have a clear and accurate document of what occurred during the meeting
• Once the document is signed, you can move on to the next step in the process.

Collect any personal items from the employee

• Ask the employee to come to the office to collect their personal items
• Make sure the employee knows they will have an escort to the office at all times
• Once they have collected their items, provide them with a form to sign, confirming that they have received all their personal items
• Ensure that all items are accounted for, and that the employee leaves with only what is theirs
• Check off this step when the employee has completed the form, and has left with all their items.

Follow up on any outstanding questions or issues

• Follow up with the employee in writing to confirm any outstanding questions or issues
• Ensure the employee has received any outstanding payments and/or documents
• Respond to any questions or concerns the employee may have
• Ensure the employee is aware of their rights and responsibilities
• When all outstanding questions or issues are cleared, you can check this step off your list and move on to the next step.

Completing the Termination Process

• Notify the employee of the outcome of the investigation.
• Draft the termination letter, outlining the details of the termination for cause.
• Have the employee sign the letter acknowledging the terms of their termination.
• Collect any company property from the employee.
• Provide the employee with any necessary documents or paperwork required by their state or local laws.
• Finalize any outstanding payroll and benefits paperwork.

You’ll know you’ve completed this step when you’ve received signed acknowledgement of the termination from the employee and have collected all company property.

Calculate and issue final payment

• Determine the employee’s final pay, including any accrued vacation, unused sick time, and other potential benefits
• Calculate and issue a final paycheck to the employee
• Notify the employee that the final payment has been issued
• Ensure that all final payment is received by the employee
• Keep records of payment issued and received
• Once payment is issued and received, you can check this off your list and move on to the next step.

Notify HR, payroll, and other relevant parties

• Notify HR, payroll, and any other relevant departments of the employee’s termination
• Contact the relevant departments and provide the necessary information, such as the employee’s name and termination date
• Ask each department to confirm they have received the notification and provide any additional information they need
• Once you have received confirmation from each department that they have received the notification, you can check this off your list and move on to the next step.

Process any necessary paperwork

• Gather all necessary documents that must be signed by you and the employee
• Collect any relevant financial documents, such as a final paycheck, and any other records that need to be signed by the employee
• Have the employee sign the termination paperwork and any other documents that need to be signed
• Ensure that all documents are filed in the right places, such as the employee’s personnel file
• Once all documents are signed and filed, you can check this off your list and move on to the next step.

Maintaining Positive Relationships

• Be transparent with the employee about their termination for cause
• Ensure the employee is treated with respect and dignity throughout the process
• Provide the employee with an explanation of why they are being terminated
• Give the employee an opportunity to ask questions and address any concerns they may have
• Allow the employee the courtesy of leaving the workplace on good terms
• Document all conversations and decisions that were made regarding the termination
• Once all conversations and necessary paperwork have been completed, you can move on to the next step in your termination for cause process.

Respond to inquiries in a timely manner

• Respond to inquiries within 24 hours
• Reply to emails, voicemails, or other messages within a day
• Follow up with any unanswered questions
• Make sure all parties have all the information they need

When you have responded to all inquiries within a day and all parties have the information they need, you can check this step off your list and move on to the next step.

Maintain a professional attitude

• Remain courteous and respectful when communicating with the employee, even if the situation is difficult or uncomfortable
• Do not make any personal attacks, even if the employee has made mistakes that led to the termination
• Listen to the employee’s concerns and be willing to answer any questions they may have
• Maintain a positive attitude and focus on how the termination is a necessary step for the company
• Avoid displaying any signs of anger, frustration, or disappointment

When you have completed the step, you’ll know it if you are able to have a respectful and professional conversation with the employee, and if you can remain courteous and understanding throughout the process.

Respect the employee’s privacy

• Ensure that any conversations regarding termination take place in a private setting.
• Maintain respectful dialogue with the employee throughout the process.
• Avoid publicly disclosing the reason for termination.
• Do not discuss the employee’s termination with other staff or colleagues.
• You will know that you have completed this step when the termination discussions have taken place in a private setting and all relevant parties have been respectfully informed about the decision.

Evaluating the Process

• Take a look at the established policies to make sure that the termination process is being followed correctly
• Make sure that all relevant documents have been collected and reviewed
• Check for any inconsistencies in the employee’s performance or behaviour that may have contributed to their termination
• Consider the employee’s tenure, their position, and the company’s history of similar terminations
• If necessary, consult with legal counsel to ensure the process is fair and compliant with all relevant laws
• Once all the necessary evaluations have been made and all relevant documents reviewed, you can move on to the next step.

Review the decision-making process

• Research relevant laws and regulations that apply to the situation
• Consult with legal counsel to ensure the decision-making process complies with best practices and applicable laws
• Review all records and documents related to the decision-making process
• Confirm that the decision-making process was fair and equitable
• Document your findings and any corrective measures taken
• When you have successfully reviewed the decision-making process, you can move on to the next step.

Analyze the outcome

• Review the decision-making process and analyze the outcome
• Consider the facts of the case and determine the best course of action
• Analyze the legal implications of the termination for cause and assess the risk
• Determine whether there is any legal recourse for the employee
• Consider the need for any additional mitigation measures
• Once you have considered all of the above, you can move on to the next step of identifying areas for improvement.

Identify areas for improvement

• Review the employee’s performance records to determine areas of improvement
• Identify any areas where the employee has not met expectations
• Determine if there is a pattern to the employee’s performance issues
• Consider any additional factors that may have contributed to the issues
• Develop an action plan to address the identified areas of improvement
• How you’ll know when you can check this off your list and move on to the next step: Once you have identified all the areas for improvement, and developed an action plan, you can move on to the next step.

FAQ

Q: What is the legal basis for Termination for Cause?

Asked by Jane on 1st April 2022.
A: Termination for Cause is a legal term which refers to the termination of an employee’s contract on the basis of a breach of contract or some other form of wrongful conduct. The legal basis of Termination for Cause varies depending on the jurisdiction, and employers must adhere to the relevant laws in the country they are operating in. For example, in the UK, employers must have reasonable grounds for terminating an employee’s contract, such as gross misconduct or breach of contract. In the USA, grounds for termination are outlined in the employment contract and can include any number of reasons that are agreed upon by both parties. Similarly, in EU member states, each jurisdiction has its own set of laws and regulations governing Termination for Cause.

Q: How do I know if Termination for Cause is appropriate?

Asked by John on 20th August 2022.
A: Deciding whether or not to terminate an employee’s contract is a difficult decision and should not be taken lightly. It is important to consider all options before deciding whether or not termination is appropriate. Generally speaking, Termination for Cause may be appropriate when an employee has committed a serious breach of contract or engaged in conduct which is deemed to be unlawful or grossly negligent. In some cases, it may be possible to resolve any issues without resorting to termination - this could include issuing warnings or providing additional training and support. Ultimately, it is important to ensure that you have considered all available options before deciding whether or not to terminate an employee’s contract.

Q: Are there any exceptions to Termination for Cause?

Asked by Mary on 6th February 2022.
A: Yes – there are certain exceptions to Termination for Cause which vary depending on the jurisdiction. For example, in many jurisdictions, it may not be possible to terminate an employee’s contract due to discrimination or if they are pregnant. Additionally, some jurisdictions may offer protection from unfair dismissal which could prevent employers from terminating employees without just cause. It is important to ensure that you familiarise yourself with the relevant laws and regulations in your jurisdiction before taking any action as any violations could lead to legal action against you.

Q: What should I do if my employee challenges their Termination for Cause?

Asked by David on 3rd December 2022.
A: If your employee disputes their termination then it is important that you take all reasonable steps to resolve the issue as soon as possible. This could involve offering them a chance to appeal their dismissal or providing them with additional information about why their contract was terminated. If your employee still wishes to challenge their dismissal then they may be entitled to bring an Employment Tribunal claim – this could result in significant financial penalties and reputational damage so it is important that you seek legal advice as soon as possible should this occur.

Q: What documents do I need when issuing a Termination for Cause?

Asked by Jessica on 18th October 2022.
A: When issuing a Termination for Cause, there are several documents which need to be provided including a written notice of termination and/or dismissal letter together with details of any agreed severance package (if applicable). Additionally, employers should also provide employees with a copy of their employment contract which outlines the terms and conditions of their employment including any applicable notice periods and/or grounds for dismissal. Depending on the jurisdiction and industry sector, additional documents may also need to be provided such as health & safety policies or details of any applicable whistle-blowing arrangements.

Q: What should I do if my employee refuses to sign documents relating to their Termination for Cause?

Asked by Amanda on 15th June 2022.
A: If your employee refuses to sign documents relating to their termination then it is important that you take all reasonable steps to resolve the issue without resorting to unnecessary legal action. This could involve speaking with your employee directly or offering them additional support such as counselling or advice from independent sources such as Citizens Advice Bureau (CAB). It is also important that you make sure you understand exactly why your employee is refusing to sign – if there are genuine concerns about their rights then these should be addressed before proceeding further with the termination process. If your employee still refuses after taking all reasonable steps then it may be necessary to seek legal advice in order to progress matters further.

Example dispute

Termination for Cause Lawsuits:

• A plaintiff may raise a lawsuit referencing a termination for cause if they believe the termination was wrongful and in violation of their employment rights or civil law.
• The plaintiff must provide evidence that the termination was wrongful and was in violation of the employment contract, state or federal laws, or civil laws.
• Settlement might be reached through negotiation or mediation, or a court may order damages to be paid to the plaintiff if they win the case.
• Damages may include back pay, reinstatement to the same or a similar job, or compensation for pain and suffering if the termination was found to be wrongful.
• In order to win the case, the plaintiff must demonstrate that the termination was in violation of the contract, state or federal law, or civil law, and that the employer failed to follow their own policies and procedures when terminating the plaintiff.

Templates available (free to use)

Termination For Cause California Notice
Termination For Cause Florida Notice
Termination For Cause Illinois Notice
Termination For Cause New York Notice
Termination For Cause Notice
Termination For Cause Ohio Notice
Termination For Cause Texas Notice

‍