Transferring Shares and Deferring Taxes Using Gift Hold-Over Relief

Understanding Share Transfer

If you’re a shareholder in a startup or private company, there are times when you may need to transfer shares to someone. Common scenarios include:

• Gifting shares to a spouse
• Selling shares to a buyer
• Angel investors transferring their shares
• Founders transferring shares to new co-founders

However, what’s not commonly known is the significant tax considerations linked to these transactions. Therefore, understanding the potential tax implications for both you and the recipient can prevent unexpected fiscal surprises.

Key Truths About Tax on Share Transfer

When dealing with transfer of shares, consider three crucial facts:

1. You may be entitled to tax relief on specific types of share transfers. For instance, Gift Hold-Over Relief can defer the Capital Gains Tax (CGT) that arises from transferring shares for free or below market value.
2. Transfer of shares to an employee is never classified as a gift by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC). If the shares are transferred from someone connected to the company to an employee or director of the company, it may be deemed an Employment Related Security (ERS). This classification means the value of the shares received could be considered income, subject to Income Tax, not CGT.
3. Share transfers can be complex, thus necessitating expert help.

For more information on tax relief options and their eligibility criteria, consult the official HMRC guidelines or a qualified tax advisor.

Tax Implications When Selling or Gifting Shares

When selling shares, you may need to pay Capital Gains Tax (CGT). Your tax liability will depend on numerous factors, including your income and the total capital gains from the share transfers during a tax year. Check HMRC’s capital gains tax calculator for more details.

On the other hand, when gifting shares, the general rule is that this is considered a ‘disposal’, which could create a ‘chargeable gain’. However, a type of tax relief called Gift Hold-Over Relief can help offset some of this CGT liability.

Leveraging Gift Hold-Over Relief

A special relief called Gift Hold-Over Relief allows you to gift your shares to another UK resident tax-free. Remember that this relief does not eliminate the chargeable gain but defers the tax liability. It means the person receiving the shares pays the tax when they later transfer or sell the shares.

To be eligible for Gift Hold-Over Relief, the conditions include:

• The shares should not be for a company listed on any recognized stock exchange. If it is, you must have at least 5% of voting rights.
• The company’s main activities must be trading.
• The recipient must be a UK resident for tax purposes.

How to Pay the Tax Owed on a Share Transfer

Share transfers should be declared on your tax return. If you claim Gift Hold-Over Relief, make sure you include a copy of the relief claim form in your Self Assessment return. Your tax liability will be calculated based on your return, typically chargeable through PAYE or in a Self Assessment payment.

Share Transfers to New Co-Founders or Employees

It is often easier and more tax-efficient for founders to issue new shares or grant share options from an existing pool. These methods are faster and involve fewer hurdles than transferring shares from existing holdings.

Legal Considerations and Conclusion

Understanding the mechanics behind share transfers can help business owners navigate complex fiscal landscapes while legally minimizing their tax exposure. The decision to transfer shares has far-reaching legal implications; therefore, consulting with qualified tax advisors is highly encouraged. The more robust your knowledge on share transfers, the better you can manage risk and legally solidify your business dealings.

If this larger view of business legality appeals to you, consider signing up for Genie AI, an AI Legal Assistant created for drafting, reviewing, negotiating, and signing all kinds of legal agreements. For access to the world’s largest open-source legal library, please sign up here.

‍